PDA

View Full Version : CHART HARVESTING Manifesto - For all interested parties


ParkTwain
12-07-2003, 07:34 AM
This is a synopsis of how I'm approaching stock selection and capital accumulation.

Look for my first installment to be posted sometime on Sunday 2003-12-07.

//PT

=========================================

CHART HARVESTING Manifesto

Copyright (c) 2003 Park Twain. All rights reserved.

----------
Background
----------


Goal
----
* Achieve RAPID CAPITAL ACCUMULATION, via trades of exchange-traded (NYSE, AMEX, NASDAQ) common stocks.
* Achieve strong rate of success in choosing stocks expected to achieve capital appreciation.
* Achieve appreciation results in as short a time as possible, with lowest risk to capital possible.

Account
-------
* IRA (no Fed income tax on short-term capital gains) cash account (no margin, no shorting)
* Low, fixed-cost commission (< $20/transaction) for each buy/sell
* No more than 80% of entire risk capital invested over any calendar 30-day period

Positions
---------
* Trade round-trips span a "near-term" timeframe of 1 to 5 weeks.
* Maximum position of $10,000 per security
* 1 to 5 total simultaneous positions (1 to 3 recommended)
* Close each position on 15% gain (after all commissions). See Trading Mechanics section below.



-----------------
Trading Mechanics
-----------------

After initial buy, place stop loss at 90% of original buy position, per security.

After a position per security reaches a 15% profit (after all commissions):

* If RSI(14) at end of day is over 70, sell the entire position only if RSI measure has broken an inclining RSI measure trend line of multi-week duration.

* If RSI(14) at end of day is not over 70 and if RSI measure is above the inclining trend line of multi-week duration, set a new stop loss at 90% of the 15% profit point, and wait.

* If RSI(14) at end of day is not over 70 and if RSI measure is below the inclining trend line of multi-week duration, sell the entire position in that security.



------------------------------
Identifying candidate vehicles
------------------------------

Daily procedure
---------------

1. Examine charts of stocks making a new 52-week high price:
http://www2.barchart.com/high.asp?=&sort=8&what=ALL&force=high%2easp

2. Examine charts of stocks making a new 5-year high price:
http://moneycentral.msn.com/investor/finder/deluxestockscreen.aspx?query=New+5-Year+Highs

3. (For stocks making a new 52-week or 5-year high price)
Look for average daily trading volume (30 days previous) in the stock of 50,000 shares. Liquidity is the friend of the short-term trader.

4. (For stocks making a new 52-week or 5-year high price)
Look for recent (more recent the better) price/volume breakout beyond a previous multi-year high price (with previous high being further in the past the better, and with previous high being an all-time high the best).

5. (For stocks making a new 52-week high price)
Look for best combination of: a) recent (more recent the better) price/volume breakout beyond a near-term (less than 3 years) previous high price, b) next significant overhead resistance is as distant as possible, measured as a percentage of the current price (no overhead resistance is best). Add this information to the comments in the published analysis.

6. After Step 4, for each remaining candidate by ranking, discriminate in favor of candidates with RSI(14) measure of 70 +/- 3 *and* with an inclining multi-week trend line for that measure. Add this information to the comments in the published analysis.

7. After Step 5, for each remaining candidate by ranking, in the Wilder's ADX plot look for a recent (the more recent the better) significant positive "jump" in the +DI line (green line) and where the multi-week trendline for the -DI line (red line) is flat or declining. OR, in the Wilder's ADX plot look for a sustained time interval that shows a separation of the +DI line above the -DI line. Add this information to the comments in the published analysis.

8. After Step 6, for each remaining candidate by ranking, identify the slope of the best inclining (most recent multi-week interval) price trend line (with the steeper the slope the better). Add this information to the comments in the published analysis.

9. Use a rough score (A, B, C, etc.) to rank the attractiveness of a new buy position for each candidate stock. Include this item in the published analysis.


Rationale
---------

* Price/volume breakout above a previous, well-established region of resistance strongly correlates with additional gains in that stock.

* In an overall bull market, a stock that shows a breakout to an all-time high (ATH), or to a price at which there is "distant" overhead resistance (defined as >50% above the breakout pivot price), strongly correlates with strong near-term appreciation, regardless of the stock's underlying fundamental value. Thus, in this scenario the probability is increased that a 15% gain is achievable and in a relatively short timeframe.

* On any day in the markets, any stock making a new 52-week (or other time period) high price might be accomplishing a breakout. Thus, by scanning on lists of new high prices and then examining the charts of those stocks for a new price gain beyond a previous high price, those stocks breaking out can be identified.

* For stocks showing a breakout that also have an RSI(14) measure that is 70 +/- 3 and that show an inclining RSI(14) trend indicate both existing strength (momentum) and also have room to grow even stronger (to an RSI(14) measure well above 70.

* A stock that shows a breakout that also shows in its Wilder's ADX plot a marked separation between the +DI line and -DI line in the recent past, or that show a trend of diverging +DI and -DI lines, strongly correlates with additional price gains in that stock.



-----------------
Using the results
-----------------

After running the daily procedure shown above, publish a listing as follows:



CHART HARVESTING(TM)
Copyright (c) 2003 by Park Twain. All rights reserved.

END-OF-DAY LISTING
2003-12-03


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Candidates from Chart Harvest(TM) from MSN Money Central Daily List of 5-Year Highs
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

AD // Symbol // AD Score // AD EOD price // Today's EOD price // Gain (loss) since AD // Comments

[Example]
2003-12-05 // CW // B // 83.55 // 83.55 // 0.00 % // 80.00 was prev 5Y (actually >16Y) peak in 2002-Jul.
2003-12-05 // EQT // A // 42.18 // 42.18 // 0.00 % // 41.50 was prev 5Y (actually >15Y) peak in 2003-Oct.


-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Candidates from Chart Harvest(TM) from Barchart.com Daily List of 52-Week Highs
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

AD // Symbol // AD Score // AD EOD price // Today's EOD price // Gain (loss) since AD // Comments [% upside to next resis]

[Example]
2003-12-05 // BAMM // A // 5.60 // 5.60 // 0.00 % // [78% >10.00]
2003-12-05 // BEXP // A // 8.22 // 8.22 // 0.00 % // [82% 15.00]
2003-12-05 // CMLS // C // 20.40 // 20.40 // 0.00 % // Approaching >3Y high of 21.50 in 2002-May. Next resis at ~55.00 in 2000-Jan.
2003-12-05 // CPRT // B // 14.23 // 14.23 // 0.00 % // [75% 25.00]




----------------------------------------------------------
Cumulative list of stock charts analyzed with A or B score
----------------------------------------------------------

5-Year Highs List
-----------------

Symbol // AD // AD EOD price // Today's EOD price // Gain (loss) // Trading days to gain 15%

[Example]
BMET // 2003-12-03 // 36.15 // 35.92 // xx // xx
BRK.A // 2003-12-03 // 84,399.98 // 84,095.00 // xx // xx
BRL // 2003-12-03 // 83.34 // 82.70 // xx // xx
BSX // 2003-12-03 // 36.14 // 35.41 // xx // xx
...


52-Week Highs List
------------------

Symbol // AD // AD EOD price // Today's EOD price // Gain (loss) // Trading days to gain 15%

[Example]
ASF // 2003-12-03 // 15.08 // 14.75 // xx // xx
BAMM // 2003-12-05 // 5.60 // 5.60 // xx // xx
BEXP // 2003-12-05 // 8.22 // 8.22 // xx // xx
BW // 2003-12-03 // 13.96 // 14.37 // xx // xx
...



-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

KEY

AD = Analysis Day
EOD = End of day
AD Score =

A : Very good candidate (expect 15% gain most quickly) due to recent breakout. Establish new position ASAP.

B : Good candidate (expect 15% gain less quickly) but price is somewhat beyond most recent breakout. Establish new position when guided by stochastics trending.

C : Price approaching next significant resistance. Set a news trigger at next resistance price and wait.

D : Price well above previous breakout and no established overhead resistance to anticipate (that is, already in blue sky or too much middling resistance ahead). Must use value analysis to determine safety of new long position, which is not the purpose of this exercise.

Mi6op
12-07-2003, 02:49 PM
Nice synopsis park I'm excited to read your upcoming picks/logic. Perhaps I should open an IRA, I'm just in a regular trading account right now in Scottrade, will they let me move 3k over (that's max right?) into an IRA? and I can fool around in my regular trading account then move another 3k over in Jan for next year?

ParkTwain
12-07-2003, 02:54 PM
In the third bullet under the section "Rationale" the second sentence reads:

Thus, by scanning on lists of new high prices and then examining the charts of those stocks for a new price gain beyond a previous high price, those stocks breaking out can be identified.


This sentence should say instead:

Thus, by scanning lists of new high prices and then examining the charts of those stocks for a new price gain beyond a previous price point or span of resistance, those stocks breaking out can be identified.


//PT

scifos
02-08-2005, 06:55 PM
ParkTwain: are you still doing this? What were the results??

ParkTwain
02-09-2005, 12:10 AM
Hi there, I'm not monitoring this board much, obviously, these days. I've not continued the approach that I described above, because it results in more data about more stocks than I would ever be interested in at one time. I was getting pretty good results from the approach, though. It was also requiring more work than I could give it, especially during an uptrending overall market.

As I posted on the new "breakout scans" thread, I am using a simple scan to set up a watch list for breakouts every weekend. I can get 20 to 30 candidates from the scan for each weekend, depending on how restrictive I want it to be (whether I limit to stocks of a certain price range, beta range, etc.), so I always get more stocks than I would ever want to be involved with at the same time. Since the market is back in an upward bias, there are plenty of candidates. I am a firm believer in a breakout seeker's discipline at this point in my life.

It's time to read "How I Made $2,000,000 in the Stock Market" by Darvas again! A good read!

ParkTwain
02-13-2005, 03:19 AM
See my post # 28 in the "Breakout Scan" thread.

I put my list of "imminent breakouts" stocks going into Monday 2/07/05 into a real-time watch list in E*Trade, so I can view the volume bid/ask volume activity (aka tape-reading).

On early Monday I bought the ANSS and BYD breakouts. ANSS faded after Monday but turned back up on Friday, so I am sticking with it a few more days. BYD broke out on both Monday and Thursday (after Wed. evening earnings announcement). I took some BYD profits on Friday and rolled into PTEN's Friday breakout.

I will have to find ways to gauge the mark of a major breakout, like that of ISRG this week. High up volume very early in the trading day is obviously an indication. I also picked up on large bid size to ask size ratio as a predictor of short-term rises during the trading day.

Not surprisingly, a lot of these setups are for uptrending stocks that are going into their earnings announcements.

Another good result of my scan criteria is that most of the losers in this list tended to be small losers (17 stocks at 0% to -2.5% for the week). This week's activity for those wouldn't disqualify them from remaining on the list for the next week.

SYNA's disastrous loss this week was based on material news about future revs (tied to Apple's iPod).


BREAKOUTS this week of stocks on the watch list:

2/07/05
ANSS, BYD

2/08/05
LACO

2/09/05
ISRG, XTO

2/10/05
BYD, LII, OCAS, PTEN

2/11/05
CSG


RESULTS for my watch list (49 stocks) for the market sessions 2/07/05 to 2/11/05, listed by % gain/loss.

Gainers: 25
Losers: 24


0% to 2.5% GAIN:
ANSS, CNX, EDO, EK, FOX, NICE, PQE, PXR, RJF, SHW

2.5% to 5% GAIN:
CSG, DD, JCOM, OCAS, POG, WSO

Greater than 5% GAIN (9 stocks):
BYD (15.65%), CBI (5.5%), CHK (5.38%), CKR (5.37%), ISRG (16.99%), LACO (8.14%), LII (5.47%), PTEN (7.39%), XTO (5.94%)


0% to 2.5% LOSS:
ACF, ARS, BCII, CNL, FINL, FL, HC, ITG, LH, LI, MCD, OIS, PPDI, RBK, SO, SONC, SVC

2.5% to 5% LOSS:
HPC, HRL, IDC, PFG

Greater than 5% LOSS:
PLMD (-9.2%), RSTI (-12.3%), SYNA (-43.08%)

ParkTwain
02-13-2005, 03:33 AM
Here are stocks that are on my "imminent breakout" watch list going into this week (2/14/05):

ACF, ADBE, AGE, AKS
BCII, BEN
CNL, CNX
EDO, EK
FL, FOX
ITG
JBHT
LH, LI
MCD, MDRX, MTD
OIS, OMC
PPDI, PXR
RJF
SHW, SII, SONC, SVC
TOO, TXI, TXT
UNT
WC
YCC

I restrict myself to watch stocks within 97% of their 52-wk. high price, with avg. daily vol. of >100K, price > $10/sh and with price and certain technical indicators pointing to an imminent breakout or at least a continued uptrend. Regarding technical indicators, I'm looking for (1) a price/volume chart that shows one significant level of resistance JUST ABOVE the most recent closing price (i.e., a stock that sits near its 52-week high in the aftermath of a recent breakout and with no significant resistance above is disqualified), (2) a RSI indicator of >60 and uptrending for at least several days prior, (3) beta >1.0, and (4) good spread and trending in the Wilder's DMI indicators for +DI and -DI and with the -DI tending to remain at or below 20 for weeks at a time up to the present (see charting at StockCharts.com).

The attached image shows the performance of my E*Trade IRA account so far in year 2005.

ParkTwain
02-20-2005, 02:47 PM
BREAKOUTS (jump above previous 52-week high, which for my scan is also at or very near the closest resistance, on at least 2X avg daily volume) for stocks on my "imminent breakout" watch list for the week of 2/14/05:

2/14/05
None

2/15/05
LH

2/16/05
AKS, TXT

2/17/05
None

2/18/05
MDRX, SONC


RESULTS for my watch list (34 stocks) for the market sessions 2/14/05 to 2/18/05, listed by % gain/loss.

Gainers: 12
Losers: 22


0% to 2.5% GAIN (5 stocks):
LI, MCD, SONC, TXI, WC

2.5% to 5% GAIN (5 stocks):
OIS, SII, SVC, TXT, UNT

Greater than 5% GAIN (2 stocks):
AKS (8.06%), MDRX (11.40%)


0% to 2.5% LOSS (17 stocks):
ACF, ADBE, AGE, BCII, BEN, CNL, CNX, EDO, EK, FOX, JBHT, LH, MTD, OMC, PPDI, RJF, SHW

2.5% to 5% LOSS (3 stocks):
FL, ITG, PXR

Greater than 5% LOSS (2 stocks):
TOO (-5.14%), YCC (-10.37%)

ParkTwain
02-20-2005, 04:49 PM
Here are stocks that are on my "imminent breakout" watch list going into this week (Tues. 2/22/05):

AGYS
BCF
CRS
FOX
MVK (resis. at 35.00/sh), MXRE
PACR, PD
SGMS, SII, STNR
TSO, TXI
UNT
WFT (resis. at 60.00/sh), WRNC
ZLC (big move on 2/18/05 that brings it up to 52-wk and all-time highs)

I also make note of the amount of Yahoo chat message traffic for each stock. All but six (6) stocks in the list above have very slow online message traffic, which correlates with the stock being underfollowed by daytrading retail investors.

Method:
I prefer to watch stocks within 97% of their 52-wk. high price, avg. daily vol. of >100K, price > $10/sh, and with price and certain technical indicators pointing to an imminent breakout or at least a continued uptrend. Regarding technical indicators, I'm looking for (1) a price/volume chart that shows only one significant level of resistance JUST ABOVE the most recent closing price (i.e., a stock that sits near its 52-week high in the aftermath of a recent breakout and with no significant resistance above is disqualified), (2) a RSI indicator of >60 and uptrending for at least several days prior, (3) beta >1.0, and (4) good spread and trending in the Wilder's DMI indicators for +DI and -DI and ideally with the -DI tending to remain at or below 20 for weeks at a time up to the present (see charting at StockCharts.com).

I take this approach to zero-in on setups with the highest probability of near-term (that is, 1 to 10 days) appreciation that also have far-away OR NO overhead resistance. In a rising overall market, this approach results in above-average probability of finding a stock that will "pop" shortly but also will keep moving up in price after the breakout.

RL
02-21-2005, 09:35 AM
Park Twain you only look at stocks within 97% of thier 2 year high can you also find stocks within 97%of thier 2 year low I'm unable to do any of that research.

ParkTwain
02-21-2005, 11:30 AM
I rely now on the Yahoo Finance stock screener, which requires that you have installed the Java plug-in for your browser. (You must also have a Yahoo ID to store your queries.) It can do what you are saying. Use the selection for "Share Performance" >> "Extreme Price Parameters (%)".

http://screen.finance.yahoo.com/newscreener.html

IIC
02-21-2005, 11:41 AM
I'm looking for (1) a price/volume chart that shows only one significant level of resistance JUST ABOVE the most recent closing price (i.e., a stock that sits near its 52-week high in the aftermath of a recent breakout and with no significant resistance above is disqualified)...Park Twain

I'm trying to figure this out. So would I be correct in thinking that you would watch to see if it blows out the resistance level?

One thought is that a stock with no significant resistance level has clear sailing ahead. I'm not saying that is true though.

Can you please clarify this a little?...I would appreciate knowing your thought process...Thanks...IIC

ParkTwain
02-21-2005, 11:54 AM
Right, I'm going to be partial to trading stocks that are right at their highest (last) level of resistance on the stock's all-time chart. So only some of the stocks at their 52-week high on a given day are also at their all-time high. But there are actually plenty of those out there right now. Also, for some stocks the highest level of resistance on their all-time chart is somewhere above their present price but below the stock's all-time high. You just have to look at a long-term chart for that stock.

If you can find a stock that is just one breakout from passing its all-time high and therefore won't feel any further overhead resistance, that is a favorable stock to be watching. That's why I don't do true swing trading -- the bounce up off of a support line has to also go through some degree of overhead just to reach the stock's next resistance level. That can/does slow down the price progress of that stock. You can look at many stock charts and see that when a stock passes a previous all-time high, the stock starts going up with a steeper slope. That's the "no resistance" effect. I believe I can make $$$ faster when I participate in these kinds of situations.

ParkTwain
02-21-2005, 11:57 AM
Look at the OXY chart. See the behavior after the stock passed 60/sh. There are many, many examples like this out there. These are the proverbial "blue sky breakouts."

ParkTwain
02-21-2005, 12:38 PM
Here's another example: SVC. Looks like we have a breakout (well, perhaps not a textbook breakout, due to not reaching 2X average daily volume that day) above a 52-wk high on Friday 2/18 (actually, its high price in 3 years):
http://stockcharts.com/def/servlet/SC.web?c=SVC,uu[h,a]daolyyay[df][pb50!b200][vc60][iUb14!Ll14]&pref=G

However, look at a longer-term chart for SVC, and you see that this breakout is nowhere near the stock's all-time high:
http://finance.yahoo.com/q/bc?s=SVC&t=my

Although SVC's breakout above its 52-wk high is good news, it still has lots of overhead to chew through to reach its next higher resistance levels (25 to 35/sh; see especially the price action from 1996 to 1998), much less to reach blue sky. So as long as there are other stocks out there that have reached the threshold of a blue sky breakout, I would not include this stock on any of my watch lists.

Runner
02-21-2005, 12:56 PM
Very good info on this thread. Notice this 10-year weekly chart of SVC. Will it take some time to work through resistance? I see your point once a stock clears resistance it has a better probability of moving up faster..

http://img88.exs.cx/img88/6577/svc5zn.png (http://www.imageshack.us)

MickyMouse
02-21-2005, 01:13 PM
Anyone use commericial charting softwares such as Amibroker. etc? I am trying to scan the universe according to the ParkTwain's rules. I am new to Amibroker, need some help. Thanks in advance.

Micky

ParkTwain
02-21-2005, 01:30 PM
I've been making my $$$ recently in casino stocks (STN, BYD) and in certain oil service (PTEN, FTO/PCO/VLO). There are lots of stocks making all-time highs to choose from in these sectors.

ParkTwain
02-21-2005, 02:16 PM
Another one I traded recently was PQUE. Check out the "max" chart from Yahoo:
http://finance.yahoo.com/q/bc?s=PQUE&t=my&l=on&z=m&q=l&c=

It is closing in on its all-time high. Actually, it looks from that chart that there were less shares traded around the area of its all-time high (middle of 2001) than have been traded just in the last few months. So although PQUE's recent prices remain below its all-time high, there isn't all that much de facto overhead resistance in this stock. You have to check whether there was any significant volume (compared with the stock's most recent trading volumes) at prices higher than today's to gauge whether significant resistance remains above today's price level. PQUE has been very strong recently and just released earnings on Feb 17.

IIC
02-21-2005, 02:16 PM
Thanks for the explanation...IIC

ParkTwain
02-23-2005, 01:02 AM
More stocks showing strength and new all-time highs with an uptrending RSI of at least 65. Most, but not all, of these are oil and energy related. Very impressive for the non-energy stocks in this group to make gains during today's very tough session in the overall market. A couple of these, like NVDA, aren't making a new multi-year high but have the next serious resistance a good distance (like up to 10/sh away) to the upside, so they have some room to move up. I may be buying a couple of these (like HAWK and MUSA) this week. Energy just seems to be a slam dunk right now, but keep your antennae up.

ACI, ATPG
BRY
CHK, CNVR, CPE, CRYP, CSL
ESLR
FST
GLBL
HAWK, HCC, HGT
KFX
LACO
MHR, MMR, MRO, MUSA
NBL, NVDA
OEH
PDC, PEO, PKD, PLLL, PVA
SGR
TGA, TIE
USAP

ParkTwain
02-23-2005, 04:10 PM
Today's one-day returns for this list:

ACI (3.49%), ATPG (1.85%)
BRY (0.45%)
CHK (1.61%), CNVR (1.54%), CPE (-0.38%), CRYP (-0.46%), CSL (0.00%)
ESLR (-0.18%)
FST (2.20%)
GLBL (0.21%)
HAWK (0.29%), HCC (0.93%), HGT (0.27%)
KFX (-0.44%)
LACO (-0.75%)
MHR (0.38%), MMR (-1.48%), MRO (0.50%), MUSA (8.20%)
NBL (0.70%), NVDA (-3.25%)
OEH (8.01%)
PDC (3.45%), PEO (-0.21%), PKD (-3.75%), PLLL (0.86%), PVA (-0.11%)
SGR (1.74%)
TGA (0.35%), TIE (0.50%)
USAP (-0.11%)